Opinion

Stop turning your life into a database

I’ve kept a journal since I was very young. They come and go in different iterations, some featuring covers with pink ponies and others simply cardstock bound, but I’ve tried to maintain the hobby. I have a notoriously bad memory, and journaling helps me return to parts of my life that I thought were inaccessible and reflect on the ways I’ve changed and grown in the time since.  

Another thing I love about journaling is that there are no rules. I’ve kept diaries in the back of chemistry notebooks, on the pre-installed word processor on my computer and sometimes on single sheets of paper. A composition book from Dollar Tree can serve as a journal as well as a 30-dollar Moleskine.  

So, I’ve been increasingly frustrated by the surge of people building “journal ecosystems” around exceptionally pricey items and stationery. If you’re unfamiliar with the term, a journal ecosystem is a system of several notebooks, each dedicated to a specific task. An ecosystem may consist of a planner, a personal diary, a commonplace book, a media log, a junk journal and so on.  

On its face, there’s nothing wrong with keeping a journal ecosystem. If you are forgetful and highly disorganized like me, I’m sure it helps with staying on top of things. But the emphasis on using, and more importantly purchasing, more notebooks than I can count on one hand reeks of overconsumption and feels highly performative.  

It’s the age-old story we’ve all been told: with just one item you can change your life! With just another purchase, you can finally begin a series of good habits and self-improvement! The commodification of journaling is no different, but it feels especially sinister to frame the world’s most accessible tool for self-reflection in terms of what can be bought and sold.  

Additionally, engaging with journaling via consumption stymies its effectiveness. When influencers or stationery enthusiasts insist that the best planner is a foreign import with the world’s highest quality paper and cutest collection of stickers, the practice of journaling becomes outward facing – the purchase and aestheticization reflects your preferences, tastes and hobbies to others rather than the self. 

I don’t mean to throw stones from a glass house. I’ve often felt that I could not start a new journal until I acquired the right materials or convinced myself that I would really stick with a planner if I spent enough money to feel guilty about not using it. I think these desires had little to do with providing myself with avenues for growth and self-reflection and more about seeming like the kind of person that would keep an immaculately organized journal, complete with stickers that perfectly communicate my immaculate aesthetic taste … something I could take pictures of in a cafe.  

And the whole point of journaling is that you keep it to yourself! Dropping 40 dollars on a genuine leather journal cover can certainly make you happy, but I highly doubt it lends itself to more effective discernment or understanding. You never need an ecosystem to start journaling or get organized; you can just start writing anywhere, on anything.  

Opinion

Opinion

View the Print Edition

September 20th, 2026

Stay in the loop