Over a week has passed since the Milwaukee Brewers swept the Tampa Bay Rays in the Major League Baseball (MLB) World Series, and the MLB offseason is officially ramping up. But the biggest question this winter won’t be the destination of the hottest free agent or the details of the next blockbuster trade—it’s whether we’ll have baseball at all.
On Dec. 1, the Collective Bargaining Agreement between MLB owners and the MLB Player’s Association (MLBPA) will expire. There has been no progress in the negotiations for a new agreement, largely due to MLB’s insistence on a salary cap that would limit the spending of big-market teams. The MLBPA famously rejected a salary cap during the 1994 season, leading to a league-wide lockout that cancelled the World Series. 32 years later, fans are fearing another shortened season as negotiations stall between both parties.
The argument for a salary cap is simple. The payroll disparity between small-market teams and juggernauts like the Dodgers is ginormous; owners claim a salary cap would help level the playing field by preventing the richest teams from scooping up all of the highest-value free agents. A salary cap would raise the competitive balance in MLB, allowing destitute failures like the Pittsburgh Pirates and Las Vegas Athletics to improve their rosters and finally make a run for the playoffs.
Easy fix, right? Surely the players making upwards of hundreds of millions a year can take a small pay cut if it means making the league fairer for everyone.
I think this is an incredibly misleading representation of the situation, and the MLB Player’s Association agrees with me.
Firstly, this year’s postseason proves that high spending doesn’t guarantee a championship. The Brewers and Rays rank 19th and 28th in payroll spending, respectively, and each team finished the season with a winning percentage over .600. These teams weren’t lucky underdogs — they dominated their divisions from Game 1 to 162. The MLB has also had six different World Series Winners in the last eight years, matching the championship diversity of salary cap leagues like the National Football League and the National Hockey Leauge.
More importantly, the relative success of the Brewers and Rays proves that the problem with most small-market teams is their cheap, lazy owners, and not their lack of free agent signings. Time and time again, teams like the Miami Marlins and Pittsburgh Pirates have allowed their most promising young players to escape to teams more willing to pay them what they’re worth. If Pirates owner Bob Nutting cared about building a franchise, they would have signed a Paul Skenes extension already.
But they haven’t. Why? Because owners care about maximizing profit, not the team’s wellbeing. Teams in the lowest percentage of payroll spending won’t suddenly improve with a salary cap. Less money will go to players, more money will go to owners and cheap teams will continue to pocket that profit instead of spending it on payroll.
Fans tired of finishing dead last every year can disparage greedy players all they want, but the truth is that a salary cap won’t fix the game. It would only give the league’s worst performing small market teams an excuse to be non-competitive while paying players (the people who do the real labor here!) even less. I’d gladly take a shortened season before conceding to billionaires desperate to bring the sport down.